In post two, he mentioned Pop's being a little pricey. Posts 5&6 seemed to say to me, again MHO, they are pricey 'cause seafood overall is pricey, so perhaps a little off topic, but more an explanation.
May be it's like "you say tow-mah-tow and I say tow-may-tow!" .
For me, Pop's is great, perhaps a touch pricey, but considering the portions, wife and I enjoy it. Thanks for posting YCNE.