I think you might have been on a bad day. I have been there a few times over the years. Never had anything I would call bad. But mostly mediocre. Ice cream was OK. No excuse for bad food though. Go back and get another meal. You paid for it. You should be able to eat it. You should have taken a picture to show the manager the next time you were in. I've done that before.

I like the Red Hill Dairy, easy in and easy out. Love the Kellerhaus, Sawyers in Gilford, and well, heck....Basically any place with ice cream is good for me.....

Have to try that new Shaved ice place in Paugaus Bay now....