Looks like a very popular website to me. You do have to remember that this site is a "special interest" type site. It's not likely that anyone in Montana would even know how to spell Winnipesaukee, let alone search for it.
If you search by just typing the term/name Winnipesaukee in Yahoo or Google, Winni.com is the 1st result on page 1 of the results before you finish typing. People would kill for that sort of SEO. (Search Engine Optimization)
Anyway... GREAT JOB Don! Keep up the good work!
Here are the numbers:
http://www.sitetrail.com/winnipesaukee.com