NH Boater -
Don't judge an "anchor line" by it's size
I got turned on many years ago to using "sail (mast) Line", it is only about 1/4" in diameter but has a 5,000# breaking strength. The down side is their is absolutely no "give" in the line.
Being in a relatively smaller boat (23') space/ storage is paramount. With this line we can easily accommodate 125' on one of those Home Depot power cord storage reels and stow easily when we depart. (yes, we carry a stern anchor too)
As for "chain" I have used chain, but quite frankly find no extreme benefit on Winni for some reason ! I know all the claims that it is heavy and lays flat on the bottom to better set your anchor -- but -- I seem to have the same luck with or without.
Finally, Aguamenti -- don't fret .... Even the supposed "Seasoned Pro's" have to set & reset at times. Setting an anchor is 25% pure luck. I have seen 32' Cruisers slipping their anchors at sandbars and that's a treat when your a 23' next to them !!
.