I have been biting my tongue on this one for a while and I finally decided to post. My wife and I visited 51 Mill St this summer and our opinion after we left was "ahhhhh it was ok I wouldn't go back."
We thought the decor inside was tired and dark. We saw no real changes/updates from the previous restaurant. The food wasn't bad but it wasn't that great either. As a matter of fact my wife's fish was covered (smothered) in undercooked onions which she had to scrape off. The place was pretty empty which should have equated to better service. Unfortunately that wasn't the case. The server was pleasant she was just a tad forgetful and slow. She was not a college student she looked to be in her 40's or so. Anyway, my overall opinion was that with all of the great restaurants in the lakes region you get one shot to impress and it hardly did that. I wouldn't tell anyone never to go there, I think everyone needs to see for themselves. Opinions do vary. I'm just saying it wouldn't make my top ten suggestions.
