Not surprising that most of the members here love the Lakes Region lifestyle! Your real decision should be made from your heart and what gives you joy!
I decided 12 years ago that a few weeks a year in the short run was better than no place in the long run. I had not been back to the Lakes region since 1984! But once I began planning for the long run and retirement it was a no brainer. I rented out the place in the summer (except when I visited for 2 weeks vacation).
Retired a year ago and spent 5 months there last year and counting down the days until I get back there. Yes a very long commute, but worth it. The added bonus is my children and granddaughter look forward to visiting from CA. every summer......