[Phantom]

Seeing as I know from whence this thread started, I will not add too much comment to the value or non value of having a VFH other than the below:

In today's age of cell phones, if you have a "real" emergancy aboard then you should have the MP number in your phone's contacts and ready to use..... It will be much faster.... However, I would also hail a MAYDAY over the VHF as there may be some "good samaritan" closer near you.

During the construction of the new MP headquarters, VHF response by MP has shifted from HQ and onto the patrol boats...... And thus sometimes sketchy. This will of course change back once they occupy the new facility.

Handhelds can hear good, but talk short distances by that I mean, you will hear all but only be able to respond to a few (transmit power low). This you may find frustrating at times.

External speaker is a must. -- as one who tried the handheld route for years, at speed with the wind, engine and boat conversation..... You will NEVER hear a thing coming from the radio.

External speaker-- for a few extra dollars, it is well worth getting an "amplified" external speaker. These boost the volume and don't sound as "tinny" as simplified external speakers

For mounting- you do not need a giant whip...... For years we operated with a 3' stainless, deck mount. Given that yours is a pontoon, I am confident there is space in the helm area for mounting one of these.....and suspect ( but don't know) that's perhaps what PJARD has.

other than that, everyone else has stated the reasons pretty on mark !


.