It seems to me that this discussion, and I am impressed with the civility on this thread, is central to what makes this country a special place on this planet.The freedom to openly debate "rights".
Check this site out. I'll bet each of us can find support in our countries history for a thoughtful stance on every issue from smoking to helmet laws to transfat.
... and what about that flouride in our water?
I'm for it if it stays at least 150' away!!
http://freedomkeys.com/rights.htm