We are heading up to the lake in just over a week and I am not leaving until I get my first lobster roll from Waldo Pepper's (this is my 4th trip and enough is enough)! However, I can't decide...should I go with the mayo or butter version. Any input? I love lobster smothered in melted butter so that sounds delicious

, but maybe the traditional style with mayo is better

. Oh what is a girl to do?????

I know I won't be able to get my family there twice, so trying both is not an option.
Please, those of you who have tried both, help me make a decision. Which is better??????