Pepper's Double Stuffed lobster roll

[PHDIII]

We tried the new double stuffed lobster roll at Pepper's today------really outstanding. Every one should try it.

[trfour]

Originally Posted by PHDIII

We tried the new double stuffed lobster roll at Pepper's today------really outstanding. Every one should try it.

Being from The Lakes Region, and enjoying the Awesome food, Lobster rolls over there since years now, before ( "The Double"
) , I have always ordered two anyways ......... " Lots of Love over there as well"
Come see and sea!
Love,
T

[SIKSUKR]

When on the lake Sunday afternoon,we planned on going to get one and finally meeting the almighty "Pepper".Unfortunatly,that big thunderstorm about 5:00 changed all that.There's always next week! SS

[Pepper]

SS, I'm sorry the storm kept you from visiting this week. Itchinforfishin' was disappointed yesterday also, when he arrived after the lightning bolt put our power out.

I'll be looking forward to meeting you when you do have a chance, but I fear that if you're expecting "almighty" I might be disappointing you! My lobster rolls are mighty good, my hugs are mighty strong, and this week is mighty hot and humid, but I'm a long way off from almighty.

[SIKSUKR]

Ok,Ok Pepper,how about "the one and only"?I actually drove down 11b from B-Maes to the weirs bridge,took a left past the restaraunt and down Paugus Bay feeling a little guilty about not stopping.I was trailering a boat which made it very difficult to find a place to park,this being motorcycle week and all,so I went to a friends place near Christmas Island to drop it and thats when the skies opened up.Just makes me want a lobsta roll even more.Are there certain days/times you don't work so I won't miss you? SS

[jkjoshuatree]

I'm sorry to say that I've never tried your lobstah rolls even though I've been coming to the lake for over 30 years. I tried two other well-known (they shall remain nameless) restaurants that are "famous" for their lobster and have come to realize that one has gone downhill (rapidly) over the past few years and the other one was marginal at best.

My family and I are staying at the Naswa July 9th-14th and you can bet that we'll be over. I've been telling my girlfriend how everyone on this site raves about your double stuffed rolls and she can't wait to try one. See you soon.

Jay

[gtxrider]

I finally went the Waldo Peppers last week. I had a single stuff and it was delish. How do you eat a double?

I met Pepper and Mr. Pepper and of coarse the question was asked "I'm from Jersey you from Jersey?" Nice people great food!
I'll be back!

[Zee]

We also went to Waldo Pepper's this weekend. Husband had their excellent shredded pork sandwich, I had the single lobsta roll. YUM. We also had the pleasure of introducing ourselves to Pepper. She is a great conversationalist and a great asset to the establishment. (aside from the lobsta rolls of course)

[phoenix]

how do you fit anymore lobster on the hot dog roll for double stuffed

[KBoater]

I did my tour(by car) of the lake today. I met Pepper and sampled the great lobster. I had a fun conversation and learned a few thing. My friend had a turkey sandwich and raved about it.
I'm putting Pepper on my tour attraction list.

[RLW]

Originally Posted by Zee

. (aside from the lobsta rolls of course)

Are you putting PEPPER second to the lobster roll?

[Resident 2B]

We have just recently bought "a place" near the Weirs, with a great view up Meredith Bay. It is something we have planned and worked for for many years.

The biggest plus is our location. The view is great, but the biggest plus is that we can take a five-minute walk to Waldo Pepper's. By far, they make the best subs in the area, possibly in all of New England. We have not, as yet, tried the pizza, but we hope to very soon. Everything they serve is very fresh, the service is great and it is a great value when you consider the quality.

I do not know Pepper (or Mr. Pepper) as yet, but I enjoy her posts to this web site. This is a totally unsolicited post. If you are in the area and looking to have a great meal, stop in to the shop located just below the red airplane as you approach the Weirs on Route 3. You will be happy you made the stop!

[Lexxi]

Hey Pepper,

How have you guys been??? I didn't think the Lobster Roll could get any better. Really sounds like you have quite a fan club !!! But then of course we knew that, cuz we were one of the first fans to start the club, but of course with some help from WaldoPeppers !!!!!

Miss you guys, see you soon.

[Pepper]

Originally Posted by Lexxi

Hey Pepper,

How have you guys been??? I didn't think the Lobster Roll could get any better. Really sounds like you have quite a fan club !!! But then of course we knew that, cuz we were one of the first fans to start the club, but of course with some help from WaldoPeppers !!!!!

Miss you guys, see you soon.

Lexxi, you were our VERY FIRST forum member fan! I miss seeing you, and can't wait for your first trip up this year. Tell me it's soon!?!?!?!?

Indeed this weekend was a wonderful collection of forum friends! I had the pleasure of visiting with GTXRider, Zee, FLBoater, JustSold and TRFour! I was even afforded the privledge of introducing two of them to one another (Man I love when that happens!)

Resident2B, if you've been in to the place you've almost certainly met me - just not formally, yet! Please be sure to introduce yourself next visit in, and thanks so much for the kind words!

Phoenix - it's a bit of a heap, and best attacked with a fork first!

GTXRider - I'm not gonna tell that big fella from Jersey that you called him "Mr. Pepper".

And to all of you - thank you, for enriching my life so much, and for making my job so very much fun!

Pepper

[Resident 2B]

Pepper, you and your staff have earned my kind words. Keep up the great work!

I will be away from the lake for a few weeks, but I will visit Waldo Pepper's sometime during the week of July 11th. We are big Nascar fans and this the big week at Loudon. This is another reason we are now "part-time" living in this great area. We are full-time Residents 2B!

[Pepper]

Originally Posted by Resident 2B

Thank you! We'll do our very best to continue to live up to your praise!

OK, Now I get it! It's not "Unit 2B" It's "To Be"! Cute! Very Cute!

[Resident 2B]

You got it.

I am now dealing with changing my "Winni.com name" or keeping it.
I wish I had the foresight of "LakeGezzer" He is way beyond my planning horizon!

See you soon!

[codeman671]

We will be up for the week of the 4th and can't wait to stop by and find out what the hype is about regarding this lobster roll. If its as good as people say I may camp out in the parking lot for the week!

[Mr. V]

For those of you (like me) who can't stand the idea of eating lobster ("giant crayfish"), do not lose heart.

They make an excellent cheese steak (get it with the works), and the pizza is real good, too.

[jetskier]

Wow, I hate to be the voice of discontent, but we went to Peppers this past weekend to try the lobster roll. My wife and I ordered the standard single stuffed lobster roll (cold, not the hot version) and we were equally unimpressed. We received a hot dog roll with a small scoop of lobster. My wife ordered fries with hers and my daughter opted for a hot dog with onion rings. The lobster roll with fries was about $11...pretty lofty for a small roll and a fairly paultry scoop of lobster salad. I would not say that it stands up to the lobster roll at McCormick and Schmidt (Boston) or even the lobster roll that McDonalds was offering a couple of years back.

Incidently, the hot dog was soggy and my daughter would not eat it. All in all pretty disappointing of over $30 for lunch and high expectations.

[rrr]

jetskier- I'm afraid you are not alone. after reading all the rave reviews here, I dragged my better half (who lives for lobster) over. unfortunately, we left with the same impression as you. I was afraid it was just us!

[jetskier]

I never thought that I would get into a debate regarding lobster rolls.

However, I agree that I probably mis-spoke calling it lobster salad. It was clearly lobster meat and mayo. However, it was a small portion on a small hot dog roll essentially heavy on the mayo and light on the lobster. IMHO, the portion was small for the $11 price (with fries) in that a lobster roll at McCormick and Schmidt (Fanuel Hall) was about $15 for a much larger portion on a larger roll with large chunks of lobster and side dishes. IMHO there was nothing special about this lobster roll and I would rate it very low. If we are focusing on improvement, here are my suggestions:

- Larger portion heavier on the lobster meat and lighter on the mayo
- Larger pieces of lobster
- A larger (potentially toasted) roll
- Lettuce is sometimes good to keep the mayo etc from making the roll soggy
- A side as a throw-in would be nice.

Sorry to disagree with the consensus, but I call them as I see them. In fairness, I never talked to Pepper about my observations and they might have been willing to make adjustments.

[Pepper]

Jetskier, rrr, and LakeLady6 first allow me to express my regret that you did not thoroughly enjoy your meal. Those who visit regularly know that I check on customers whenever I am able, and I want to know EVERY TIME about ANYTHING that is not satisfactory. Apparently I was not able to check on you while you were dining, or perhaps you opted not to raise the flag, if I did stop by your table.

With regard to the portions available, we offer our standard single-stuffed roll, which weighs precisely one quarter pound, and our new double-stuffed roll, which weighs precisely one half pound. This weight is carefully portioned on a digital scale. As is typical of this time of year, we have many new staff members, and some are still learning how we do things. It is entirely possible that you received portions that contained only smaller pieces, and too much mayo. This could be a result of failure to stir properly, or some other failure to follow our procedures. There is no excuse for this, and I will vigilantly guard against it happening again. You have my word on this.

With regard to the portion and the pricing, lobster prices are currently at record high. We honestly feel the $9.75 price for the standard single stuffed and $16.95 for the double stuffed are extremely fair. Additionally, we couldn’t agree more that lettuce in the roll is a key factor in keeping the lobster from making the roll limp. That’s why every lobster roll is served on a grilled roll, with a small nest of shredded lettuce placed inside before stuffing with lobster. For those that prefer ungrilled rolls, or no lettuce, we happily accommodate those requests.

We’re glad that each of you have posted your experiences, and hope that on another occasion you’ll try us again. We sincerely hope that if your next visit is not ONE HUNDRED PERCENT satisfactory, that you will bring it to our attention at once! Customer satisfaction and enjoyment are our NUMBER ONE PRIORITY!

[Lake Lady 6]

Now that a few different opinions have appeared I feel better about sharing my experience with a Waldo lobster roll. After reading the postings this past winter I was looking forward to trying their lobster roll - was not impressed at all - hot dog roll with a small amount of lobster. Is there a different lobster roll available that the forum members order which is "double stuffed"? Sawyer's has a much better lobster roll just packed with lobster meat & little mayo.

We did not introduce ourselves but Pepper was there. Everything we have read is true. Great personality, very accommodating, great smile and made the visit worth our while.

[BroadHopper]

Originally Posted by Lake Lady 6

Sawyer's has a much better lobster roll just packed with lobster meat & little mayo.

LL6, I live near Sawyer's and I have not seen this on the menu. I'll check again. Ever since the boys took over the establishment from their father, I have seen the service and food quality go way down. I have not frequent this place much. When Double Decker at Winnisquam and the Boulevard Drive In on Weirs Boulevard close, I have yet to find a great drive in to eat. The Tamarack is mediocre. I have to travel to Center Harbor to get good fried clams. I'm not a lobster roll fan but my Mom is. I like to take her to Pepper's as she says the best lobster rolls she had are in Kennebunkport, ME.

[rrr]

Pepper- You were not there when we were - maybe that's what was missing! I'm sure we will be back.

BroadHopper- where in the port? Alison's is great!

[IslandSib]

The lobster catch at the lake has been down lately, but Waldo Peppers does their best to give us a taste. Whether it is your taste or not is for you to decide. I myself have had a difficult time concentrating at work while I await my next trip to Waldo Peppers to try out this double stuffed lobster roll. Love the lobster and thoroughly enjoy my time with Pepper.

[trfour]

Originally Posted by IslandSib

The lobster catch at the lake has been down lately, but Waldo Peppers does their best to give us a taste. Whether it is your taste or not is for you to decide. I myself have had a difficult time concentrating at work while I await my next trip to Waldo Peppers to try out this double stuffed lobster roll. Love the lobster and thoroughly enjoy my time with Pepper.

Hi IslandSib,
GOD, some peaple are tough to please!.... I have said this out here somwhere before,..... (" If you want to enjoy a lobster roll, comparable to the ones at WaldoPeppers, you need to take a trip about 800 miles north of here, to; Cape Breton Island, NS. Canada..... However, you will find, that Pepper doesn't live there!.. Isn't She Precious?..!")....

Love,
T.

[GWC...]

Originally Posted by BroadHopper

LL6, I live near Sawyer's and I have not seen this on the menu. I'll check again.

My grandmother loved Sawyer's lobster roll and she died 10 years ago. Guess it has been available for a little while.

Two years ago, I tried the lobster roll at Waldo's and enjoyed it, also.

My keyboard does not take kindly to moisture, so must say, "Enjoy!"

[GWC...]

Originally Posted by BroadHopper

LL6, I live near Sawyer's and I have not seen this on the menu. I'll check again.

When you are inside, look at the sign on the wall and look below "sandwiches" and you will notice two columns. The top of the right column lists lobster and if you desire a plate, look under "plates" at the bottom of the left column.

Sawyer's lobster roll is a single of equal portion and taste to Waldo Peppers.

Speaking of which, it takes two hands to handle a GWC special - that would be a large sub roll filled with two double stuffed Waldo Pepper Lobster orders - plenty of roll and plenty of lobster.

Yes, GWC was there as Pepper enjoyed some nutrients at a table.

P.S.- Between a GWC special and a Sawyer's regular and a quart of Sawyer's frozen pudd'n ice cream, I am one happy guy!

Thanks to all involved, you made my day!

[rrr]

went back to Pepper's last week while on vaca. hubby had the double stuffed - it took him a minute (or two) to figure out how to eat it - but he loved it! as we sat there we found ourselves saying 'I want to try that, and that, and that...' so we took a menu to plan our next visit!

the walk back to the docks at the Weirs was a little slower - we were both so full!

(must've just hit an off day on our first visit)

[IslandSib]

When you go back ...add the onion rings...
NO one can say no to onion rings.

[Pepper]

rrr, I'm delighted to know that your second visit was much better than the first! No need to eat your words, though! If your first visit was unsatisfactory, you had every reason to say so. Besides, if you eat your words you'll have no room for the onion rings.

Please be sure to introduce yourself next time you visit. I love to put faces with screennames.

[billhurley]

My wife and I were in last night. She ordered the Lobster roll and I had the biggest cheeseburger ever and fries. It was awesome as always.

[phoenix]

We have been stuck in Phoenix for much of this summer. temps well over 100 but thankfully we will get to the lake in mid August and are longing for Pepper's famous lobster roll

[SAMIAM]

I love to figure these things out....ok,let's see...Jetskier wants "larger portions and bigger pieces" for $9.75.....wholesale lobster meat,at this moment is $19.75 for the claw and knuckle mix that is usually used in lobster rolls.That's almost $5 for a quarter lb.Now add .20 for the roll,another .35 for the mayo,napkin,holder and fork and you have a whopping 55% food cost(the national average is around 32% for restaurants of that type.Now add payroll,mortgage,huge utilities,taxes and other overhead.
As near as I can figure,that greedy Pepper is milking you out of 10 or 15 cents every time you buy one.
Looks to me like that is a HUGE bargain.....

[jetskier]

I really was going to stay out of this...but you goaded me back in.

The pricing of lobster rolls in the area appears to be fairly standardized. Sawyers is $9.95. In Mass Papa Ginos is $10.95 and McCormick and Schmidt is $15.00 with sides. The portions from all of these establishments appears reasonable; clearly 1/4 lb or more and heavy on the lobster.

1/4 pound of lobster meat with claw sections is quite reasonable...but that is not what we had. There was a "scoop" heavy on the mayo and very light on the lobster. There was no semblance of any claw meat...the roll was not toasted and there was no lettuce. Basically, it was lousy. Now anyone can have an off day and we are willing to give Pepper another shot. But the prior posting positions me as being unreasonable and I take great umbrage to that!

Jetskier

[SAMIAM]

Tsk,tsk.....don't take it personal...just having a little fun at your notion that everything would be fine if they were a little heavier on the lobster.When you go to the bank,do you ask the teller to just throw in a few extra dollars?
Restaurants don't generally just throw food on a plate.You're getting a specific amount of food for a set price....just like the grocery store.If you find the portion a little small for you,I'd suggest the double.......but you've got to pay the price.

[On Barndoor]

Just wanted to add my 2 cents on the great lobster roll debate. After reading the forum comments, we went last week for a round of "double stuffeds", with pizza for the kids. All were thrilled with the meal; one of, if not the, best lobster rolls around. As an extra bonus, Pepper was kind enough to let our dog hang out under the picnic table while we ate - not many spots on the lake that will allow that! A big thank you from Baxter, Pepper. Hopefully we'll be back soon.

[GWC...]

Originally Posted by SAMIAM

If you find the portion a little small for you, I'd suggest the double...

Or, you may opt for the GWC Special - plenty of lobster and plenty of roll.

[dpg]

O.K. now I'm confused. Haven't been in Peppers yet but I always thought (he) was a guy. I read most of this thread and saw a lot of "she's" thrown in there. Well, what is it now I'm curious? I will definitely stop by but not for lobster (not my favorite.) I will say however I did stop at the Tamarack, we got in line took a look at their prices and left. They are very high and now I understand under new management. Their onion rings (used) to be great however nothing fancy any more.

[Zee]

DPG - Pepper is an attractive redhead. You can't miss her. If you are not into lobster, try the barbecue pork sandwich. It is great as well.

[upthesaukee]

I agree with the barbeque pork sandwich plaudits, as does Mrs UTS, and quite frankly, even the lowly Hamburger/Cheeseburger flies high at Waldo Pepper's.


See you later this week, Pepper.

[upthesaukee]

of peppers can be found...Habeneros, Jalepenos, Pablanos, etc... But, TR, you are correct: there is truly only one Pepper!!!!!

[trfour]

Thanks for the back up, UP!!


Love,
T.

[Pepper]

Y'all are makin' me blush ... again!

I thank you for your kind words, TR, and UP. And of course you both know how I feel about my customers.

How lucky am I to have so many wonderful ones!!!

[SIKSUKR]

Well,I finally met the one and only Pepper.What a treat!Your personality was not all overstated.That place must be a very safe place to be cuz when I was there,no fewer than 4 police were eating and Pepper was siitting and chatting with them.As far as the food,my girlfriend ordered the single stuffed lobster roll and thought it was great.I did manage to steal a bite and had to agree.I had a choice of a 1/2 or whole roast beef sub and made the mistake of ordering a whole.My god that thing was huge!Actually it wasn't a mistake cuz after the fireworks ,I brought home the other half and ate it then.Same conclusion on the sub,very good and filling!I will certainly be back for more.It was nice to put a face on a name Pepper.I bet you didn't think a SIKSUKR looked like me.Or maybe you did!!

[Lin]

just got back from the lake. Friday my daughter and I went to Weirs beach, down to Walmart and TJMax and a few other places. While at Weirs I told her I'd buy her lunch at Waldo Pepper's. She said she'd never eaten there and wanted to eat at the pier. Anyhow on the way back from Walmart she said okay I'll try it. This was my second time in a week stopping there with family. This time we both ordered the lobster rolls and thoroughly enjoyed them. My daughter just like my husband several days prior said we'd found a new eating spot. Delicious food and good helpings surrounded by very pleasant people. On the way out, we met Pepper at the counter and talked a spell about the lake and the forum. So glad to have finally met you Pepper!! Thanks for a great meal.

[Pepper]

Originally Posted by SIKSUKR

... I bet you didn't think a SIKSUKR looked like me.Or maybe you did!!

Kinda like a wolf in sheep's clothing! Actually, you don't look sick, and you certainly are no sucker! Otherwise, you wouldn't have that beautiful and personable lady by your side. Hope you two drop in again real soon. I'm looking forward to more laughs! So glad to have finally made your acquaintance.

Here's were I wish I knew how to quote more than one person in a post!

Lin, I thoroughly enjoyed meeting you and your beautiful daughter also!!! I'm glad your family is all in agreement, because I'm looking forward to seeing all of you again, too!

I am so truly blessed to have the honor of meeting so many wonderful people because of this forum. What Don has created here is absolutely magical, and we are all so fortunate to have this great place to come to and share. I've met so many of you that I've lost count. When I think about how this forum has brought so many of us together, it's really overwhelming. Thank you, Don, from the bottom of my really huge heart.

[phoenix]

Hey Pepper with all these accolates maybe you can run for Governor Well anyway will finally get back up to the lake this weekend and look forward to a lobster roll

[DRH]

Originally Posted by phoenix

Hey Pepper with all these accolates maybe you can run for Governor Well anyway will finally get back up to the lake this weekend and look forward to a lobster roll

If she doesn't run for Governor she might need to put a big addition on WPs to hold her fast-growing number of fans ... er ... customers!!

[Pepper]

You guys are all so great.

I'd like to post a special Thank You to GWC who has emailed me with instructions on how to post quotes from two different members in one reply. Hopefully my first attempt at doing so, below, will be successful.

Originally Posted by PHOENIX

Hey Pepper with all these accolates maybe you can run for Governor Well anyway will finally get back up to the lake this weekend and look forward to a lobster roll

Thanks for the vote of confidence, Phoenix, but no thanks! I'd like to keep all the friends I've made!

Originally Posted by DRH

If she doesn't run for Governor she might need to put a big addition on WPs to hold her fast-growing number of fans ... er ... customers!!

Maybe my neighbor, Lakehouse, will sell me some of his high land, and we can build a bigger Waldo's - with a view! Then I'll have to put a webcam in the pilot's seat.

Hey, look! It really worked! Thanks again, GWC!

[phoenix]

Pepper what are your hours Sunday hope to get down for a special lobster roll

[upthesaukee]

According to their website, Waldo Peppers is open from 11-8 on Sundays.


Here is the link: www.waldopeppers.com

Look for the redhead, and introduce yourself. Prepare yourself for a good Philadelphia/NewEngland style hug!!!!!!!! Enjoy the food and the company.

[trfour]

Enjoy all of the great food, and get to meet more of the very special Forum people here!... Log on and register today @ winnipesaukee.com
Love,
T.

[Pepper]

Jeepers! I guess I'd better get my website updated, because it's incorrect! YIKES! We're actually open from 11:00AM till 7:00PM on Sundays.

Phoenix, I hope you two are able to make it there before seven - I'll be keeping an eye out for you! Glad you're finally able to get back north - it must feel cool up here to you guys after the heat you've had this summer. Looking SO forward to seeing you again!

[upthesaukee]

It's OK Pepper, I fixed it. I went back to the website, went to the hours section, and took a little piece of paper, wrote 7 PM on it, and taped it on my monitor over the 8 PM. Whew, I won't make that mistake again.


See YA!

[phoenix]

brought the whole family yesterday for lobster rolls( five plus one calzone). Also got to see a number of web siters including Don . Thanks Don for ( as Pepper would say) for making this forum possible. Pepper will see you again later in the week.

[LSBA Joker]

Another happy customer yesterday when the 'informal' winnie.com meeting was happening.
brought Mom, (a lobster fiend bostonian living in lobster-free Vegas), my wonderful spouse and my 2 line handlers in for a 1st visit to WP's.
why have we not visited b4?
when will we visit again(with neighbors, guests, etc in tow)? SOON!

Nice to meet you, Pepper, as well as the tableful with the neat shirts.