Boating Accident/Death off Diamond Island

[PC31]

Originally Posted by sa meredith

Curious if this post is pointed at me?
My honest thought is that thereis just too much evidence that alcohol played a rolled here...way too much. The .15 alone would normally be enough.
But the right attorney can show any evidence to be circumstancial...and that's what I believe happened here.
Maybe I'm wrong.
But here is a captain who grew up on the lake. She can probably navigate and operate a large boat as well,if not better,than anyone who reads this forum. And yet we are to believe she made the decisions that she did, with a clear head? Doesn't add up.
I think many people in the area know her, and consider her a friend, so they get their ire up when they comment on this matter. But the events of the evening seem to have taken a course that intoxication would explain.
Not trying to offend anyone. This is just my opinion.

Were you intoxicated when you wound up in the witches? Obviously the prosecutor did not prove that .15 was accurate.

[sa meredith]

Originally Posted by PC31

Were you intoxicated when you wound up in the witches? Obviously the prosecutor did not prove that .15 was accurate.

Really...you think that an appropriate analogy???!!! Really???
Strange, but I'll bite...
Visibilty was simply as far as the eye can see...bright sunny day. No real reason to not be cruising along.
There were no beer can/bottles empty/full on board. No booze of any kind.
I had not spent 5 hours in a bar that day.
I had consumed no alcohol in the previous 24 hours.
Realizing my insanely stupid/ careless error, I STOPPED IN TIME!

I don't want to do battle with you...really.
But you think these are the same things?

Honestly...my only real questions here, are given her amount of experience (which I believe to be substancial), how can she have made some of the deciisons that she did.
Really, it comes down just one decision...she stated visibility went to zero...but powered back up because her passengers were feeling ill.
That does not sound like the logic of a clear thinking person.
If I'm wrong, I'm wrong.